I want to know if I'm dealing with a hypocrite who watches it and jerks to it but judges the people in the videos.
A guy not wanting to date a porn star doesn't make him a hypocrite. It could be a simple question of wanting to be in a monogamous relationship. If I was still dating I wouldn't necessarily want to date any of my favorite girls in porn despite jerking off to them. The two things are not interrelated. Also, welcome to the mind of a guy. Most guys don't need to like a girl in order to fuck her, or at least jerk off to them. Dating however is entirely different.
Secondly it gives you a bit of an upper hand because what man wouldn't be a little bit intimidated dating a porn star? It will make him step his game up sexually and it turns the tables....it's usually the girl who is the one self-conscience going into a relationship.
This is kind of a douchy move; because "usually the girl who is the one self-conscience going into a relationship." Guys aren't purposefully making them self-conscience. Girls do that shit to themselves. Instead of wanting to place it on guys, why not want more girls to become less self-conscience?