Just out of curiosity, Chef, which pitcher and hitter do you consider the best, in modern times. Calling Barry and Roger "far" from the greatest is interesting...
The best pitcher, IMO, is Greg Maddux. Cliche choice, I know...but he is one of the few pitchers to actually have success by being a good
pitcher.
Modern day pitchers are mostly power pitchers who do nothing but throw the ball as hard as they can when they're on the mound. Are they effective? Sure they are, but being born with the ability to throw hard doesn't impress me. What
does impress me though, is Maddux's ability to pin point the accuracy on his pitches. The man has pitched nearly 5,000 innings in his career and has walked less than a 1,000 batters, while keeping a career ERA of 3.11 (as of today). Also, Maddux has won 15+ games in 18 of his 22 seasons. His first two seasons accounted for two of the years that he didn't win 15 games and in the other 2 seasons he still managed to record 13 wins (2005) and 14 wins (this past year).
That impresses me. Maddux doesn't rely on a 100+ MPH fastball to get his opponents out. He relys on good pitching, plain and simple.
Other notables: Tom Glavine, John Smoltz, Nolan Ryan
The best hitter, IMO, is Tony Gwynn. He is by far, the greatest pure hitter to play the game in modern times. Hitting isn't just about putting up huge numbers, especially when it comes to HR's.
I'm not taking anything away from Barry Bonds, as his career BA is nearly .300 and he is good for a pretty decent amount of HR's every single year. The problem with Bonds is that he's only good at "swinging away". He can't slap a ground ball when needs to, he can't aim his hits and he certainly can't lay down a bunt when the time calls.
Tony Gwynn's career BA is .338, but that's not the most impressive thing about him. He worked magic with his bat on a daily basis. He didn't just step up to the plate and heave his bat at the ball, hoping to get a hit. Tony Gwynn hit the ball where
he wanted it to go. If there was 1 out with a runner on 2nd, Gwynn would know that his job was to get the runner to 3rd base...not swing for the fences. He knew that what he had to do was either hit a deep fly ball into right field or slap a ground ball towards the right side of the infield, which would allow the runner to advance. Tony Gwynn did this with
consistency. Gwynn also had over 9,000 at bats and only struck out 434 times. INSANE!!!
Other notables: Pete Rose, Kirby Puckett, Edgar Martinez