Yes he was. R.I.P. Mr. Caan.
Yes, he was a gifted actor but ...
The thing with James Caan that I couldn't ever stand was at the fortieth anniversary of
The Godfather in 2012. Some foundation honored the filmmaker and actors. There they took questions from the audience. Francis Ford Coppola, Robert DeNiro, Diane Keaton, Al Pacino, Robert Duvall, and James Caan were all present on stage. I'm not sure if Talia Shire was there.
Anyway, someone from the audience asked Al Pacino what it was like to work with John Cazale. Mr. Cazale, of course, played the character of Fredo Corleone. Al Pacino started talking about him since he knew John the best, working with him in the late 1960s in off Broadway plays, and then later in
The Godfather,
The Godfather Part II and in
Dog Day Afternoon. [I know the whole story, since the HBO documentary
I Knew It was You: Rediscovering John Cazale was televised in 2009.]
Robert DeNiro also knew John well. He put up insurance of several million dollars to keep John Cazale's character in
The Deer Hunter. At the time, John Cazale had already been diagnosed with lung cancer and the studio Universal Pictures was afraid that Mr. Cazale would pass away before the movie was completed. Causing Michael Cimino to recast the role and then Universal would be out those scenes adding millions more to the film's budget.
However, James Caan interrupted Al's story with utter nonsense. And the conversation changed focus and it went in a totally different direction from there. How rude is that? The audience never got to hear Al's story.
If you want to see them -- both the HBO documentary and the Fortieth Anniversary discussion on
The Godfather -- they should both be on youtube.