Yes, thanks for getting the name right this time. Shows what you know anyway.
As for all this ROY hooplah, the hometown White Sox fans obviously are in love with their team and refuse to acknowledge the evidence. Aside from his batting average, Longoria has superior statistics across the board. Stats aren't eveything, that's true, but stats do not lie, unlike your inherent bias toward all things White Sox.
The Rays have the second best record in baseball while playing in the toughest division and Longoria has to be given some credit for that. His defense is superb and none of his teammates are having great seasons offensively. I mean, look at the rest of the lineup: Pena is nowhere near where he was last season and was injured for a major part of the season, Upton and Crawford have very average batting averages, they have a pretty weak lineup when you really break it down. I would give more credit to their pitching staff than to their lineup, but you can't give Ramirez more credit than Longoria. Not when you have teammates like Quentin, Dye, Thome, Pierzynski, Cabrera, Crede, Konerko, and Swisher helping to carry the offensive burden. Plus, the White Sox have an inferior record in a weaker division.
Where's the argument? Better overall stats on a more successful team with a weaker lineup vs. worse overall stats on a less successful team with a stronger lineup. Plus better defense from Longoria as well. Try backing up your argument for Ramirez with information and evidence as strong as that instead of just saying catch phrases like "he's meant more to his team" without giving reason or evidence to back it up.
As for A-Rod, he is nowhere near deserving of any kind of reward this season. The Yankees have a monstrous payroll and are FOURTH in their division(thanks to the Jays hotness of late). His stats are good, but all of his HRs come in blowout games. He's been terrible in clutch situations. His average with runners in scoring position is .264 with only 6 HRs. 22 of his HRs have come with the bases empty and 11 while leading off an inning. A-Rod is the worst clutch hitter. I'd rather have Craig Counsell at the plate in a pressure situation than A-Rod.
Yes I am a bit bias for the White Sox,but obviously you haven't watched shit for White Sox baseball because if you did then you would know that Ramirez HAS been one of the players that has been carrying the team.Yes,having Quentin, Dye, Thome, Pierzynski, Cabrera, Crede, Konerko, and Swisher seem like a good thing,but how good is it when most of the players that you named were either hurt or playing like shit for a decent part of the season?
I'm pretty sure that I've watched more Sox games than you have this season,so you can throw what ever stats you want to but the facts are that when most of the Sox players were playing like shit,Alexei was one of the few,along with Quentin,Dye,and A.J.,who was actually playing good and he still is playing good now.Plus Alexei was playing lower in the line up so those guys were not protecting him.
Like I said before,If Evan wins it,I won't be pissed off,but would the Rays be where they are today without him?Maybe yes maybe not,who knows,but I'm pretty sure that you can subtract about 5 or so games from the record if the Sox didn't have Ramirez.