((Where is Blue Countach anyway....he will get a kick out of this))
"Patriotism is the last refuge of a scoundrel."
~Samuel Johnson
"All boys love liberty, till experience convinces them they are not so fit to govern themselves as they imagined."
~ Samuel Johnson
Here you go. That quote doesn't quite represent what the good doctor intended.
Courtesy of Christopher Hitchens.
The world of political jibberjabberers cleaves neatly into those who go around saying, “Patriotism is the last refuge to which a scoundrel clings,” and those who do not. You don’t hear patriots using this line because we aren’t particularly alarmed by patriotism (at least in the context of fidelity to the ideals of the UK or USA. I might question Myanmar patriotism). And was the line that clever to begin with? It says nothing except that those who claim patriotism are scoundrels. That’s a feeble ad hominem attack. Were it an utterance of Jimmy Carter instead of Samuel Johnson, it seems safe to say, no one would find it particularly astute. But if Carter used it, it would reveal something about the speaker, wouldn’t it? Using this line is simply hiding one’s lack of pride in country under the tattered shelter of a copy of Bartlett’s.
Now Christopher Hitchens speaks elegantly on the matter, and as it turns out the line doesn’t even mean what it seemingly says–but something close to the opposite. I didn’t know that the capital-P Patriots were an extremist group, subversive radicals whom the proud Tory Johnson strongly disliked. It was those who claimed allegiance to this particular party whom he denounced. I think liberals should shut the door on this quotation, tiptoe silently out of the room, and let it sleep forever. Dr. Johnson was one of us: a patriot.
I quote Hitchens’ opening graf from his latest Atlantic review:
How often our usage manages to accomplish, for a name or an expression, the precise negation of its originally intended meaning. To satirize the sycophants among his courtiers, King Canute sarcastically commanded the waves to keep their distance and allowed his own majesty to be wetted by the tides: now we give the name Canute to anyone in authority who foolishly attempts to ward off the inevitable. For the young scion of the Veronese house of Montague, only one girl in the whole world could possibly possess meaning, or be worth possessing: accordingly, we use the word Romeo to designate a tireless philanderer. In 18th-century England, John Wilkes was the leader of a radical political faction known as the Patriots. In Dr. Samuel Johnson’s Tory view, affiliation with that subversive party was “the last refuge of a scoundrel”: this now is construed as an attack on all those—most often Tories themselves—who take shelter in a too-effusive love of country.