Mike Mignola disagrees...and he was there while it was being made!
Where did you hear that? I always was under the impression Mignola was quite satisfied with the first Hellboy movie (the second one I don't know).
I always thought that Del Toro's movies are great only when they aren't based on some existing comic book franchise. I'm a huge hellboy fan, but the movies were eh. And I hate the Blade movies...but I seem to be alone there.
I was pretty impressed with both Hellboy movies. Especially the first one. But you're right, they're both not that close to the comics. But I had no problem with that.
I really liked the first and second Blade movie. Blade:Trinity was ok, but nothing special. I wouldn't want to imagine how bad it would have been without Jessica Biel and Parker Posey. I don't see however, how this is del Toro's fault... He directed the second one, yes, but he was hired into a completely designed and determined franchise. He himself said, that his "room to move" had been pretty small, and I'd say he made the best of it.
PS: Speaking of Mignola, The Amazing Screw On Head is up on YouTube in three parts (for now). The art and character design is directly inspired from Mignola's work, the animation is top notch and Paul Giamatti does the voice acting. It's much better than the Hellboy animated stuff IMO.
"The Amazing Screw-on Head" really is great, no, I'd even say it's perfect. Too bad it wasn't picked up for a whole season. One more example for the ignored and misunderstood genius of Bryan Fuller. Without his virtuosic and superb writing skills, the pilot would never have been produced, but it still wasn't enough to make SyFy give it a full season order. This man has constant bad luck. First Showtime and MGM butcher and finally cancel "Dead Like Me" (mind you that was at a time when MGM was still mostly run by strongly prejudiced conservatives (Fuller even had to remove the only gay character from the show) and before Showtime realized the potential of controversial paytv and brought us shows like Weeds, Dexter, Californication or lately Nurse Jackie and United States of Tara). Then FOX kills his new project "Wonderfalls" by putting it on the friday night death slot before even giving it a chance and cancelling it after only four episodes. He finally gets his hands on a hit franchise ("Heroes", which interestingly took a creative nose dive after Fuller left after season one), which gives him a new shot at a show of his own, "Pushing Daisies", which is then again killed, this time by two strikes in a row and very bad programming by ABC. This man has absolutely no luck.
Del Toro's a very talented director, amongst the best working today I would say, to go on and work on other projects may be the right move for his career, rather than having to spend six years on the same one.
I'd agree with that. Let's see what he comes up with next. About a year ago he said he'd like to do a movie which is a mixture of Ridley Scott's "Alien", John Carpenter's remake of "The Thing" and Lovecraft's "Mountains of Madness". That I'd like to see.
What, you don't like three quarters of your movie to be in shot in slow motion against a green screen that seemingly shows and represents absolutely nothing?
Sucks to be you fella....
I don't see the problem.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/1c4fb/1c4fb4a004ac374ae735c210f8560be0dce354ac" alt="Big grin :D :D"
Snyder is a style genius. He knows exactly how to get the images he wants. And don't forget that he is responsible for the arguably best horror remake of all times, "Dawn of the Dead". That movie is even better than Romero's original. I'd even go so far as to say that it's the best Zombie flick ever made. It's definitely the most realistic one so far. Thus, just because most of "300" and large parts of "Watchmen" were shoot in front of a green screen doesn't mean the man doesn't know his craft.
I really hope he does the "Heavy Metal" remake he once talked about. After that I'll probably build a shrine for him.