Favorite Whiskies and Bourbons

[FreeOnes_Adam]

I never had Rye. Silly question, does it have any flavor at all, akin to the seeds in rye bread?

Caraway seeds is that unique thing you taste in those breads. Rye in itself is just a super close relative of the grasses barley and wheat.

 

[Petra]

I never had Rye. Silly question, does it have any flavor at all, akin to the seeds in rye bread?

Oh, it's packed full of flavor and it does have nuances of american rye bread. Now, I discovered rye whiskies at the london ******* festival last year and had 3. Whistle Pig which is an american rye, Lot 40 which is Canadian and Millstone 100 which is Dutch. Just to get me to taste it again, the Whistle Pig rep had to put some maple syrup into it. But the Lot 40 and Millstone had a very pleasant spicy bite while not being obnoxious like whistle pig. Now, at that time I wasn't into high ABV whiskies so I'm hoping Whistle Pig will be there again this year so I can have another crack and see if my opinion has changed with my developing taste.

But out of all the rye, Millstone is my favorite.

Knob Creek does a pretty decent rye as well. If you have a total **** or someplace that allows you to taste, try it out and see if you like it.

 

[Harpsman]

Neat - Jameson
Hot - Powers

 

[fred_mirc]

all Kilchoman, lot of Arbeg and some Bownmore it's my best scotch (Islay).

 

[Petra]

Well, there's only about 1 dram left in the Dark Cove. There may be fight coming up to see who gets it.

 

[Petra]

Made an Old Fashioned this past weekend using the Millstone 100 Rye and compared it against one made with Makers Mark. It was a real treat to the tastebuds. I'll have to use Knob Creek to compare it against an American rye now.