Two absolutely stunning photos!
But ultimately, this contest is about determining which photo comes closest to visual perfection.
After a thorough comparison, there were 2 takeaways that factored in my decision:
- The use of the curtain: though a brilliant and novel move, its deployment falls short of perfection as it would've been better (imo) to have it completely behind the model, i.e., left out of the tub.
- While Whirlpool of Desire shows some signs of post-production/retouching, the Voyeur's View image appears to be considerably more natural.
Overall, I find Voyeur's View to be the better of the two pics!