South Park is the thinkers comedy. ****** Guy is just offensive, slapstick type ****. There is always a reasoning or cause behind South Park. ****** Guy is just jokes written on napkins drawn out for a cartoon. I love them both, although, American *** has surpassed ****** Guy IMO. It's a good mix of the two. You get your offensive humour with a touch of social commentary. I laugh out loud every time I watch it.