Kurt Cobain

Let's face it,Nirvana was just doing what The Pixes had been doing for years beforehand.

As could be said for most anyone whom has ever picked up an instrument or microphone. The Pixies were influenced and included elements from all sorts of previous genre and artists. They were not making something out of thin air from scratch.

Hendrix was actually great, without him many of the top guitarists would never have played guitar.

Hendrix did things with technology that changed virtually all genres of pop music forever, for example.

When you consider one of the attributes of grunge was the heavy distortion and contrasting sound dynamics being made, it could be said that Jimi Hendrix was the grunge of his time in that regard. Not the first, but the one that made others take further notice and by doing so the approach gained popularity and others followed. Was he a great tactician on the strings absolutely, but was it over blown comparatively as well like Cobain? I mean without the newly created (few years) wah-wah pedal (heck pedals in general were pretty much new at the time), would he even had stood out as much? Surely someone else would have came along and created the same or quite similar sound via just simple experimentation with the new technologies and what they allowed as they came about. This coupled with a confidence to move forward in divination from the norm of others at the time, surely there would have been someone else. He was certainly not the first even to mess with distortion, people were fucking with amplifiers and poking holes in speakers along with all manner of techniques for distortion 20 years before Hendrix broke out.

Hendrix, like Cobain came along at the right time with the right mix of attributes and became the influence in a moment in time. And like Cobain upon death, the persona gained even further when coupled with the drugs and counterculture attitudes, each took on a myth and legend of their own.

Joplin proved that someone with enough passion and soul could not only be popular regardless of their attractiveness, but she brought issues to light, was socially relevant, and championed several traditional songs.

Similar to Cobain also. He didn't have a mainstream look (hair colors, etc), not attractive to most, certainly had passion and soul, championed a cause at the time with his songs and was socially relevant even though he didn't care to be.

i think you gotta keep in mind that most everyones experience with nirvana are the 2 songs they play on the radio.

For the vast majority of people across the world, this holds true. The songs the record companies push and the radio stations play (movies use, etc) is the only encounter most will have with any band, group, music. This is not unique to nirvana, its common with any music or artist for the majority of people.
 

alexpnz

Lord Dipstick
Noel Gallagher>Kurt Cobain.

The Beatles were proven, over time, to be average at best when Oasis and The Verve came along and improved on what they did.

Factoid.
 

Killer B

I Like Big Tits! (song by Joe Walsh)
Kurt was a gifted song writer, decent guitar player and mediocre at best singer. Nirvana put out some solid songs but in my opinion, are overrated. I'd rather listen to Pearl Jam, Soundgarden, Alice In Chains and Dave Grohl's Foo Fighters.
 
Good songwriting, historically important but somewhat overrated because he died prematurely. Personally, the entire genre he represented is a bit too nihilistic for me to be a major fan. Life's depressing enough without wallowing in it.



Billy Joel??? GenX?? How could a guy who reached his peak in the late 70s be on your list, Scott? Not criticizing, just curious. Seems a really odd choice to go with the others you mentioned.
This fucking tool: http://www.google.com/#hl=en&tbo=d&...429,d.aWc&fp=f62974a305da139d&biw=976&bih=588

You see, that's how much I care about him - I didn't even know his name.

To be fair we killed 'Dookie' back in junior high when it came out but I quickly lost interest in them for some reason.

It's really too bad Lady Gaga, Justin Bieber and Nicki Minaj can't follow in Kurt Cobian's lead ... :suicide:
Add lil Wayne to that list and maybe Brittney Spears, too. :D

Kurt was a gifted song writer, decent guitar player and mediocre at best singer. Nirvana put out some solid songs but in my opinion, are overrated. I'd rather listen to Pearl Jam, Soundgarden, Alice In Chains and Dave Grohl's Foo Fighters.

Kurt's voice was great, IMO. It was raspy as shit for a reason, sort of like Bob Dylan. It was so ugly it was beautiful.

One of the best songs ever:

 

alexpnz

Lord Dipstick

alexpnz

Lord Dipstick
Go and suck a fart out of someone's ass.

:D
Go and post more horseshit about that Anders dude or that Regina whatever the fuck her name is....:facepalm:
 

meesterperfect

Hiliary 2020
Brilliant songwriter?

Overrated trash?

Historically important?

Just some guy that made some mediocre albums and killed himself?

No poll. Discussion is encouraged.

No, but he had talent.
No.
Yes.
No.
Thank you for the encouragement.

I'm a nirvana fan. I think I now have almost everything audible that they recorded.
I like most of it.
I liked Kurt, any Dinosaur Jr. fan can't be all that bad.
 
Very Overrated! Not a fan, Sorry!

Cheers
Jason-X :cool:
 
kurt cobain was a good musician, his music was good, lyrics didn't make much sense.
he was a good artist
very bad for himself.
a little overrated, usual for dead artists.
amy winehouse likewise, she sucked as an artist.
 
Top