This is kind of a weird opinion. If this were a girlfriend that u dated for like 3 weeks and then one day found out she had a deformed foot, then yeah, i think u'd be a little shallow for breaking up with someone who u admired and liked just because of their foot. But you just clarified for us that you would love to be with this girl above others simply because of the way she looks. I mean this is porn, and we are objectiving these women, u like kate because she's hot, not because she's a nice person, but because she looks good. That being the case I think people are free to be turned off by her foot, and while it is shallow, it's no worse then u not liking some other girl because she has pimples all over her face.