georges said:
There is one point where I disagree. Palestinians are basically migrants from other arab countries.You forget that in the 20's-30's some Jews from Euroipe migrated to Israel.Israel is a developped country and a true democracy as compared to most of its neighbours.
US is hated by the Arab world because of its culture and because it has dared to fight terrorism in Afghanistan and in Irak too.The persons who hates US in the arab world are those islamist fanatics. Israel fights terrorism by all the means, it is hated in region because not only it had defeated its agressors in 1967 and 1973 but also because it is one of the strongest military force in the region.
You also failed to mention that Israel has its own military indutries (Israel Military Industries and Isreal Aircraft Industries).Israel built its own tanks (merkava), guns (galils, jerichos, uzi, tavor, galatz, desert eagle (now built by mri), planes (kfir c2 and c7)) and missiles (shaffrir, pithon, rafel,etc). The only planes baught by Israel to the us were the b17 inthe 50's,a4 skyhawk in the 60's-70's,f4 phantomII in the 60's, f16 in 80 mid 90's and f15 in the early 80's late 90's.Israel has an enough advanced military and technology industry to be independant.
Back to the subject, Arafat was offered a chance to have peace during clinton's presidency but he failed to grab it because he was unable and probably unwilling to stop the terrorist groups and dismantle them once for good.
I don't see a problem of US backing up Israel, democracies must help democracies as well as fighting terrorism together.
Just another info, not all the palestinian suicide bombers were that poor because most of them were educated person who had a great income but they were endoctrined to hate the jews. Even at palestinian schools, scholar books describe the jews as bad people so the responsability of the chaos that happens is mainly due to the Palestinians who supported Arafat and who supported terrorism against Israel.
You seem (IMO) to know your military hardware.
But, as usual, we disagree on a few points.
1) I am not Palestinian or Arab (and I assume, neither are you). So neither of us knows what is in the hearts of those people as to why they 'hate' the U.S.. I disagree that most Arabs/Muslims hate US culture. Their religious fanatics do. But I do not think that is why most do. I think that they hate the U.S. budding in where it was not wanted and for backing Israel so strongly. You disagree. Fair enough. I have no opinion polls of Arabs/Muslims to back up my arguement. If you do, I would be interested in seeing them.
2) I agree that democracies should help other democracies. But the Palestinains are fighting to get their own democracy, and Israel will not let them. Why is this SO different (in principle - not methods) then the American Revolutionary War? The U.S. wanted to be free of England. England did not want to let them go. So Americans (and apparently a huge number of French soldiers also) killed as many British as they could to gain their objective. Now suicide bombing innocent civilians is cowardly in the extreme. And militarily stupid in my opinion. But how else should they do it? Israel simply will not let them go. So how do you suggest they do it? Not how should they do it. I suspect that we both know of more decent ways to do it. But they have tried for a generation to be free and Israel will not relent. Can you really not see why after all this time and all their poverty compared to Jewish Israeli's (average per capita GDP at 1/28th of Jewish Israeli's as of 2003), why they are resorting to such desperate (and stupid) acts? I can see why. I don't like it or agree with it. But I understand it. And if I was a child raised in that situation, I may be doing the same thing (though I would hope not).
3) Finally, militarily. You are right that Israel has developed a powerful (for it's size) defence industry. But I look upon it as the Japanese were until 20 or 30 years ago. They built better mouse traps. Not new types of mouse traps. They just took ideas from the west and improved upon them.
The Kfir and the Python are good examples. The Python, I have read, is a great AA missile. I have also read (at
www.globalsecurity.org for one source) that the Python is basically a reworked Sidewinder.
And the Kfir came out of necessity. The Frence stopped selling Mirages to Israel. But Israel liked them. So they took a slightly reworked Mirage III airframe and stuck a F-4 Phantom engine (the J79) in it. Well engineered, yes. But hardly leading edge technology.
They tried to buid the Lavi; but I read that basically the U.S. nicked the idea because it would compete too closely with the F-16.
And that is my point. The Israeli military (especially the Israeli Air Force - and without an Air Force, you are virtually nothing as a powerful military wannebe) is TOTALLY dependent on the United States. If you go to the above mentioned website amd check out Israel's Air Force (the IAF) you will see that the Kfir (which is a J79 engined Mirage, basically) and one small transport plane are the only aircarft on the entire Israeli inventory (outside of remotely piloted aircraft, and many, many countries can build those) designed and built by Israel.
Europe long ago stopped selling to Israel (I assume so as to not piss off the Arabs and their oil) so the U.S. is it in the West (as far as I know).
Also, according to the CIA World Fact Book, in Fiscal Year 2002 Israel spent $9.11 Billion U.S. on defence. That is 8.7% of their total GDP. That is a very high percentage (the U.S., in comparison in FY 2003, spent 3.3%. France 2.6%) of the GDP. A country, I would imagine, would have a hard time sustaining that indefinitely without it significantly affecting their overall
economy.
But since Israel gets $3 Billion U.S. from Washington (which is almost entirely in the form of military equipment or money for military equipment - or so I believe) then that means that the Untied States is, in essence, funding fully 1/3 of Israel's defence budget.
So I disagree with you when you say that Israel could go it alone. Without the U.S., I believe that Israel (especially when Iran gets nukes) would no longer be the dominant military force in the Middle East. Especially once their spare parts started drying up for all those sexy, state-of-the-art fighters they get for (basically) free from Uncle Sam.
Do I want Israel to be defeated? No. I just want them to let the Palestinains have the West Bank and the Gaza strip for their own. And I want the US to stop backing Israel so strongly and to pull out of Iraq completely once the elections are over. And then mind their own business and concentrate on getting Bin Laden - militarily speaking.
Hard to believe this is a porn site, huh?