Is Terrence Malick overrated as a director?

[bnaked]

Many top movie stars are lining up to work with Terrence Malick after he returned from a self-imposed 20 year hiatus from directing. However, a lot of actors he has worked with have been critical about his directing/editing style, saying that the narrative of the film gets lost in all the long poetic shots that he uses. He also ends up editing much of the actors' dialogue and performances out of his films. Is Malick overrated as a director? Why or why not?