A few people have brought it up in comments, but Amateur Allure used to feature girl-next-door types (mostly unknown local talent from Arizona). Nowadays all they have are either pornstars or chicks on their way to becoming pornstars, looking to make a name for themselves in the business. I don't know if "Thomas" has retired as a performer, although he still runs the site. The dude had a tiny cock but he shot thick, massive loads. More importantly, though, he got true amateurs almost exclusive to the site.
Either way, it would be sort of fun to do a "Where are they now?" thread about all the classic babes Thomas had back in the 2000s. Like I heard "Kathleen" got married and moved to Texas. "Paige" got hitched, too. "Nanet" fell off the face of the earth after some of her classmates recognized her. Cousins (supposedly) "Matilda" and "Marquelle" were supposed to do Exploited College Girls but I guess people they knew irl found out they were on AA and so they never did it. Who am I forgetting?
Either way, it would be sort of fun to do a "Where are they now?" thread about all the classic babes Thomas had back in the 2000s. Like I heard "Kathleen" got married and moved to Texas. "Paige" got hitched, too. "Nanet" fell off the face of the earth after some of her classmates recognized her. Cousins (supposedly) "Matilda" and "Marquelle" were supposed to do Exploited College Girls but I guess people they knew irl found out they were on AA and so they never did it. Who am I forgetting?