Hey guys and (some) girls,
In an earlier topic I tried to discuss the ordering of the values of equality, freedom and community. The general consensus seemed to be that everyone who didn´t put freedom on top was not a true american, or perhaps not even a true westerner.
Now I think this opinion is respectable, but there is a slight improvement that might be, to make it more correct.
I think that everyone who said that, assumes that freedom means equal freedom for all. Freedom without that assumption might mean a caste society where the upper caste have absolute freedom (freedom is maximised).
Everyone who ranks freedom as the ultimate value is, in my view, debating with the assumption that equality is already taken care of.
This would mean however that equality is the ultimate social value, and not freedom.
What do you think about this? Are we all secretly egalitarians?
In an earlier topic I tried to discuss the ordering of the values of equality, freedom and community. The general consensus seemed to be that everyone who didn´t put freedom on top was not a true american, or perhaps not even a true westerner.
Now I think this opinion is respectable, but there is a slight improvement that might be, to make it more correct.
I think that everyone who said that, assumes that freedom means equal freedom for all. Freedom without that assumption might mean a caste society where the upper caste have absolute freedom (freedom is maximised).
Everyone who ranks freedom as the ultimate value is, in my view, debating with the assumption that equality is already taken care of.
This would mean however that equality is the ultimate social value, and not freedom.
What do you think about this? Are we all secretly egalitarians?